You're not just losing a few bucks in fees. You're losing every fan who tips you — their name, their email, their phone number, their next booking. Here's what nobody tells you about using Venmo for tips.
Look, we get it. Venmo is easy. It's already on your phone. Your friends use it. Slapping a Venmo QR code on your tip jar takes thirty seconds.
But here's what you need to understand: Venmo was built for splitting bar tabs with your roommate. It was not built for musicians trying to turn a weekend gig into a sustainable career.
And that mismatch isn't just costing you a few dollars in fees.
It's costing you your future.
Let's get the obvious stuff out of the way first. Venmo charges 1.9% + $0.10 per transaction for business payments. On a $20 tip, that's about $0.48. On a $150 night, you're losing maybe $4.
Is that annoying? Sure. But if fees were the only issue, we'd tell you to just deal with it.
The fees aren't the issue. The issue is what happens after the tip.
And relationships are where music careers are built.
Picture this: You're playing a Friday night gig at a local brewery. You're killing it. A woman in the front row is loving your set. She tips you $15 on Venmo and requests "Piano Man." You play it. She sings along. Everyone cheers.
And then she leaves.
Gone. Forever. You have no idea who she is. No way to reach her. No way to tell her about your next show. No way to let her know you're available for private events.
Two weeks later, she's planning her husband's 50th birthday. She wants live music. She vaguely remembers that guy who played Piano Man at the brewery. What was his name? She can't find him. She hires someone else.
This isn't hypothetical. This is what happens every single weekend to thousands of musicians who treat their tip jar like a transaction instead of a funnel.
A fan scanned my QR code at a bar gig. She requested "Piano Man" and tipped $10. Because I was using TipTree instead of Venmo, I captured her email address automatically.
Two weeks later, I sent an email to my fan list mentioning that I was available for private events.
She replied: "I'm planning my husband's 50th birthday party. Are you available March 15th?"
I was. I quoted her $2,600. She said yes.
If I'd been using Venmo, I would have gotten $10 and never heard from her again. Instead, I got $2,610 — and a client who has since referred me to three of her friends.
This is what Venmo costs you. Not $4 in fees. Thousands in missed opportunities.
No app required. No account required. Works for everyone — young, old, local, tourist, doesn't matter.
You wouldn't show up to a gig in sweatpants. You wouldn't hand out business cards printed on napkins. So why is your tip setup a handwritten sign that says "Venmo: @CoolGuitarDude87"?
Your tip jar is part of your brand. It's one of the only things fans interact with directly during your set. And right now, it's telling them you're an amateur.
Think about it from a venue owner's perspective. They're considering you for a residency. They see your Venmo sign. It looks like something a college kid would set up for a dorm room concert.
Now imagine they see a clean, professional QR code that leads to a branded page with your photo, your bio, and a sleek tip interface.
Which musician looks like they take their career seriously? Which one gets the callback?
Every time someone tips you on Venmo, who benefits?
Venmo gets the transaction data. Venmo gets the fee. Venmo gets another data point for their advertising business. Venmo's valuation goes up.
What do you get? Some money, minus fees.
You're building Venmo's database with every tip. You're not building your own.
Which musician has a career? Which one is just gigging?
Scenario: You play 100 gigs a year. Average $120 in tips per gig. About 10 tippers per show.
| Venmo | TipTree | |
|---|---|---|
| Gross tips | $12,000 | $12,000 |
| Platform fees | -$310 | $0 |
| Lost tips (friction) | -$2,000 (est.) | $0 |
| Fan emails captured | 0 | 1,000 |
| OTO sales | $0 | +$1,500 (est.) |
| Private bookings (from list) | $0 | +$2,500 (est.) |
| Net value | $9,690 | $16,000 |
Real results from real artists who made the switch
"I switched from Venmo eight months ago. I've already booked three private events from my email list — over $4,000 in gigs I never would have gotten. TipTree paid for itself in the first month."
"The OTO feature alone is worth it. I sell my EP to about 15% of tippers. That's an extra $200/month I was leaving on the table with Venmo."
"I used Venmo for four years. Zero emails captured. Zero private bookings from tips. Switched to TipTree, and within six months I had 300 emails and two corporate gig inquiries."
If you just want to collect some cash tonight and start from scratch tomorrow, use Venmo. It works fine for that.
But if you want to build something — a fan base, an email list, a booking pipeline, a career — then you need a tool that was built for musicians.
Every gig you play with Venmo is another room full of fans you'll never see again. Another potential booking that'll go to someone else. Another night of working hard and building nothing.
The switch takes five minutes. The difference lasts a career.
Get Your Free TipJarNo credit card required. You keep 100% of tips. Cancel anytime.