TipTree
How Does It WorkPricingCalculatorLog InGet Started
Get Started Free
The Musician's Honest Assessment

PayPal Was Revolutionary.
Twenty Years Ago.

It's clunky. It's dated. It takes the biggest cut. And it captures exactly zero information about your fans. Here's why PayPal is the worst choice for musicians who want to build something real.

Scroll to read

PayPal was the first. We'll give it that. Back when digital payments were new, PayPal was the only game in town. But that was 2004.

Since then, PayPal has become the AOL of payment platforms — technically still around, coasting on name recognition, while the world moved on.

And yet musicians keep using it. Maybe because it's familiar. Maybe because they set it up years ago. Maybe because they don't know there's something better.

There is. And the gap between PayPal and a real musician-focused platform isn't even close.

Chapter One

PayPal Takes the Biggest Bite. And Gives You the Least.

Let's talk fees. PayPal charges 2.99% + $0.49 per transaction. That's the highest in the game.

On a $20 tip, you keep just $18.91. On a $150 tip night, PayPal takes about $5.50. Over a year of gigging twice a week, that's $570+ gone to a company worth $70 billion.

Same zero emails as Venmo. Same zero fan data as Cash App. But somehow, more money out of your pocket.

And that's before we talk about the holds, the disputes, the frozen accounts...

On PayPal
What you get from a $20 tip
  • $18.91 (after 2.99% + $0.49)
  • A PayPal email (often a junk account)
  • Highest fees in the game
On TipTree
What you get from a $20 tip
  • $20.00 (you keep 100%)
  • Real first and last name
  • Personal email address
  • Phone number & location
  • Complete transaction history
PayPal gives you money and a dead end.
TipTree gives you money and a relationship.

That relationship is worth infinitely more.

Chapter Two

PayPal Might Be the Worst Tipping Experience on Earth

We're not being dramatic. Try to tip someone on PayPal from your phone right now. Time yourself.

Your fans have to: Have PayPal installed (or use the clunky mobile website), log into their account, find the "Send Money" option (not obvious), enter your email address correctly, choose "Friends & Family" vs "Goods & Services" (confusing), enter an amount, confirm payment, and possibly complete 2-factor authentication.

That's NINE steps. And if they choose the wrong payment type? You get hit with extra fees. If they misspell your email? Money goes into the void.

9 Steps
To tip you on PayPal — versus 3 on TipTree

Every step you add loses 10-20% of potential tippers. How many tips have you lost because someone gave up halfway through PayPal's checkout flow?

Chapter Three

The Booking You'll Never Get

The Lost Opportunity

Somewhere right now, someone wants to hire you.

A guy tips you $20 at a restaurant gig. He loves your sound. He's thinking his wife would love you for their anniversary dinner next month — maybe a private house concert type thing.

But it's late. He's tired. He figures he'll look you up later.

Later never comes. He can't remember your name. The PayPal notification just says he sent money to "musicianpayments@gmail.com." That doesn't help him find you.

You lost a $500-$1,500 gig because PayPal gave him no way to reconnect with you. If you'd had his email, one follow-up message could have turned that $20 tip into a $1,000+ booking.

PayPal makes that impossible.

Chapter Four

The Demographic Disaster

PayPal's core demographic is online shoppers aged 35-55 who've been using it for eBay purchases since 2008. Your fans at a Friday night brewery gig? Mostly 25-40 year olds who use Apple Pay for everything.

With PayPal 9 steps

1 Have PayPal installed (or use clunky website)
2 Log into their PayPal account
3 Find the "Send Money" option
4 Enter your email (spell it right)
5 Choose Friends & Family vs Goods & Services
6 Enter an amount
7 Confirm payment
8 Complete 2-factor authentication
9 Finally submit

With TipTree 3 steps

1 Scan QR code with phone camera
2 Tap a tip amount
3 Pay with Apple Pay, Google Pay, or any card

No login. No account. No decisions to make. Works for literally everyone.

PayPal feels old. When a 28-year-old sees a PayPal.me sign,
their first thought is "does anyone still use that?"
Chapter Five

The PayPal Problem Nobody Talks About

Ask any freelancer or small business owner about PayPal, and you'll hear the horror stories:

PayPal has a reputation — earned over two decades — of treating small users as guilty until proven innocent. One weird transaction, one customer complaint, one algorithmic flag, and suddenly your money is locked up for 21 days.

As a gigging musician, can you afford to have your tip money frozen for three weeks because some automated system flagged your account?

Chapter Six

PayPal Builds PayPal.
TipTree Builds Your Career.

Every PayPal transaction benefits one company: PayPal. They get 2.99% + $0.49 of your tips, transaction data for their business, user engagement metrics, and fuel for their $70 billion valuation.

What do you get? Some money (minus their cut). Nothing else.

TipTree flips this equation. Every transaction builds YOUR assets: your email list, your fan database, your booking pipeline, your marketing power.

After 1 Year on PayPal
  • Some money (minus highest fees)
  • 0 usable email addresses
  • 0 booking leads
  • No growth, no data, no assets
After 1 Year on TipTree
  • Some money (100% of it)
  • 500+ contacts
  • Complete fan insights
  • Direct line to everyone who supports you

One path leads somewhere. The other is a treadmill.

Chapter Seven

The Objections (Let's Be Real)

"I've had PayPal forever. Everyone knows my PayPal."
Do they though? How many fans actually remember your PayPal email or PayPal.me link? And even if they do — great, they can send you money. But you can't reach them. You can't invite them to shows. You can't tell them about private events. Familiarity isn't worth much if it leads nowhere.
"PayPal is trusted. People feel safe using it."
True 10 years ago. Less true now. Most people under 40 view PayPal as clunky and outdated. And "trusted" doesn't mean "convenient." People might trust PayPal, but they don't want to go through the hassle of using it for a $15 tip. Trust doesn't matter if the experience is bad enough to kill the transaction.
"I don't want to learn something new."
TipTree takes five minutes to set up. It's simpler than PayPal ever was. And here's the thing: you already know your current system isn't working. You're not building a fan list. You're not getting private event inquiries from past tippers. Five minutes of setup for years of compounding growth. That math is easy.
"The fees aren't that bad."
PayPal's fees are the highest of any major platform. But forget the fees — they're the smallest issue. The real cost is every fan who bounced off PayPal's clunky checkout. Every booking inquiry you never got because you had no email addresses. That cost is thousands per year. The fees are a rounding error.
Chapter Eight

The True Cost of PayPal (Annual)

Scenario: You play 100 gigs a year. Average $120 in tips per gig. About 10 tippers per show.

PayPal TipTree
Gross tips $12,000 $12,000
Platform fees -$540 (worst in class) $0
Lost tips (friction) -$2,800 (est.) $0
Fan emails captured 0 1,000
OTO sales $0 +$1,500 (est.)
Private bookings (from list) $0 +$2,500 (est.)
Net value $8,660 $16,000
+$7,840
More per year with TipTree — and that gap compounds every year

What Musicians Like You Are Saying

Real results from real artists who made the switch

★★★★★

"I switched from Venmo eight months ago. I've already booked three private events from my email list — over $4,000 in gigs I never would have gotten. TipTree paid for itself in the first month."

DM
Derek M.
Acoustic Solo Act
★★★★★

"PayPal's fees were killing me — almost $50/month just in their cut. Now I keep 100% and my fans actually complete the tip instead of giving up halfway through checkout."

DR
Devon R.
Cover Band Frontman
★★★★★

"A bride booked me for her wedding because I had her email from TipTree. She'd tipped me $10 at a random bar gig eight months earlier. That's a $2,500 booking PayPal would've made impossible."

AK
Stephanie M.
Harpist
The Real Question

What Do You Want Your Tip Jar To Do?

PayPal had its moment. That moment is over. It's a legacy platform with legacy fees, legacy friction, and legacy thinking.

But if you want to build something — a fan base, an email list, a booking pipeline, a career — then you need a tool that was built for musicians.

PayPal was built for eBay sellers in 2004.
TipTree was built for you.

Stop Using Yesterday's Tools for Tomorrow's Career.

Every PayPal tip is a transaction that goes nowhere. A fan who wanted to support you, lost to a clunky checkout flow. A booking that'll never happen because you have no way to follow up.

The switch takes five minutes. The difference lasts a career.

Get Your Free TipJar

Five-minute setup. 100% of tips. Cancel anytime.